The story of System 1, and System 2.
|Sep 23, 2018||Public post|
Let’s get straight to the point. We’ve got two modes of thinking: System 1 (Thinking Fast) and System 2 (Thinking Slow).
Let’s take a (classic) question.
A bat and ball cost $1.10 in total. The bat costs $1.00 more than the ball. How much does the ball cost?
What’s the immediate answer that comes to your mind? Hold it in your head, and now glance at the image below.
As quickly as you see that the photo is black and white and of a man, you know he might be angry as well. You also sensed that this man is about to break his guitar, probably while shouting his lungs out. A premonition of what he is going to do next comes to your mind automatically and effortlessly. It is an instance of fast thinking using System 1.
Now look at the following mathematical problem: 17 × 37
You know immediately that this is a multiplication problem. You probably also know that you can solve it, with pen & paper or calculator. However, without spending some time on the problem, you can’t find the right answer.
Try to complete the multiplication (in your head) now.
If you have actually tried to carry out the computation in your head (which most likely you haven’t), you might have realised that it is a bit of a strain. You’ve felt the burden of holding a lot of stuff in your memory. The process consists a lot of mental work: deliberate, effortful, and orderly. It is an instance of slow thinking using System 2.
System 1 is the part of the brain that handles the simple things: sensory input, automatic and unimportant decisions, casual social interactions, and other inbound signals that can be processed rapidly and rather easily.
System 1 is rapid and instinctive. It does not involve what we usually associate with ‘thinking’. When you duck unexpectedly because a ball is thrown at you, or get nervous when you look down from the rooftop of a skyscraper, or smile when you see a funny meme on 9GAG, you are using System 1. These activities are associated with the most primitive parts of the brain.
System 2 is the higher-order, logical part of the brain. It’s the part that thinks at the speed of the voice in your head. It brings processing power for decisions and problems that require deeper thought.
System 2 is more deliberate and self-conscious. We use it while learning to drive, when deciding which flight to take to London, and whether to become an engineer or a doctor.
All Indians have a System 1 reaction to a temperature given in Celsius but have to use their System 2 to process a temperature given in Fahrenheit; for Americans, the opposite is true. People speak their native languages using System 1 and tend to struggle to speak a new language using System 2. Being truly bilingual means that you speak two languages using System 1. Professional chess players’ System 1 allows them to size up complex situations rapidly and to respond with both amazing accuracy and exceptional speed.
System 1 is your gut reaction and the System 2 is your conscious thought.
System 1 can be trained with lots of repetition — but it takes a lot of time and effort. One reason why newbie drivers are such risky on the road is that their System 1 has not had much practice, and System 2 is much slower.
The workings of the human brain can be befuddling. Beethoven wrote his incredible ninth symphony while he was deaf, but he often misplaced his house keys. How can we be so ingenious at some tasks and so clueless at others? If you think about all the things the brain is constantly handling — it’s not just impressive, it’s insane. But you’re able to do it because the part of your brain that you’re aware of, System 2, is always outsourcing the bulk of the work to System 1.
The fox knows many things but the hedgehog knows one big thing .
Decades ago, the philosopher Isaiah Berlin wrote an essay that compared the styles of thinking of great authors through the ages. To organise his observations, he drew on a scrap of 2,500-year-old Greek poetry attributed to the warrior-poet Archilochus: “The fox knows many things but the hedgehog knows one big thing.”
Think of System 1 as childlike. Just like 5-year-olds view everything in terms of cause and effect — and has absolute certainty about the things they know — this part of the brain will either believe something with great conviction or not. Nothing in between. It’s like the hedgehog.
Think of System 2 as a beleaguered, overworked but very intelligent manager. System 1 is the army of interns that she’s hired to solve all the simple problems she can delegate — even though they mess some of them up.
System 1 has no time for, ‘This thing has a 30% probability of being true.’ That’s System 2. And the thing about System 2 is that it’s always looking for evidence that something isn’t right or isn’t to be believed. It’s nuanced. It’s a sceptic. It’s like the fox.
Systems 1 and 2 are both active whenever we are awake. System 1 runs automatically and System 2 is normally in a comfortable low-effort mode, in which only a fraction of its capacity is engaged. System 1 continuously generates suggestions for System 2: impressions, intuitions, intentions, and feelings. If endorsed by System 2, impressions and intuitions turn into beliefs, and impulses turn into voluntary actions. When all goes smoothly, which is most of the time, System 2 adopts the suggestions of System 1 with little or no modification. You generally believe your impressions and act on your desires.
Now that you’ve got a fair amount of idea about how our brain takes decisions, what’s your System 1 answer to the bat and ball question? Think of another answer using System 2. Do they match?
Support: Thanks for reading! If you want an easy way to support my work, please consider becoming a patron for $2/month.